
Comparing Construction and Materials
First, we’ll compare how they’re made. At a glance, the two Saatva mattress toppers and Dormeo’s Premium Mattress Topper have similarities, however there are distinct differences to know about.
Cover Material
Mattress toppers for both brands start with breathable covers. Saatva uses 100% organic cotton fabric, While Dormeo is a polyester. Breathable designs are important for helping to regulate body temperature by allowing better airflow. On the Saatva mattress toppers, the organic cotton fabric also wicks moisture to keep sleepers dry and comfortable.
Foam Layers
How do the foam layers compare? The Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper uses advanced, body-contouring memory foam infused with naturally cooling graphite. As for Saatva’s Natural Latex Mattress Topper, it contains a layer of responsive, breathable latex.
Dormeo’s topper has viscoelastic Recovery FoamTM and polyurethane foam springs known as Octaspring®. There are mixed reviews online for the support of the topper, with some sleepers expressing there is not enough support for them.
Safety Certifications
Saatva’s Graphite Memory Foam Topper and the Dormeo one use CertiPUR-US® certified foams. CertiPUR® certification means the foams are free of formaldehyde and toxic chemicals like mercury and lead. The respected label also means they meet low VOC (volatile organic compounds) emissions standards. That can make for a healthier, safer topper.
Saatva’s Natural Latex Mattress Topper is also a more eco-friendly topper, using eco-INSTITUT® certified natural latex for low pollution and VOC emissions. It also has a Forest Stewardship Council certification for sustainably sourced materials. For shoppers looking to reduce their impact on the planet, these certifications are important.
Hypoallergenic and Antimicrobial
Those with allergies often look for hypoallergenic mattress toppers to reduce discomfort for better sleep. The Saatva Natural Latex topper and Dormeo use hypoallergenic materials, with both Saatva toppers also having a feature that sets them apart. Saatva treats its two toppers with Guardin™, a plant-based antimicrobial treatment. That means these Saatva mattress toppers resist bacteria, mildew, and mold growth, as well as allergens and dust mites. That can help them be part of a healthier bedroom.
Saatva Mattress Topper vs Dormeo: Size and Thickness
A mattress topper must fit the mattress that’s already on your bed. The Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper comes in many sizes:
- Twin: 38″ x 75″
- Twin XL: 38″ x 80″
- Full: 54″ x 75″
- Queen: 60″ x 80″
- King/Split King: 76″ x 80″
- California King: 72″ x 84″
Dormeo offers a similar size range, plus specialty RV mattress topper sizes.
Saatva’s Graphite Memory Foam topper and Dormeo are both 3″ thick. The Saatva Natural Latex Mattress Topper is 1.5″ thick for a gentle upgrade.
Ease of Care
How easy are they to clean? Dormeo’s topper has a removable, machine washable cover. While the two Saatva mattress toppers are not machine washable, they are straightforward to spot clean. The Saatva US website recommends spot cleaning their mattress toppers with mild soap when needed.
Saatva’s latex mattress topper is hypoallergenic because it goes through a washing process that removes allergens, as per its US site. People with latex allergies, however, should always talk to their doctor before using any latex product.
Stability and Security
Even the right size mattress topper needs features to prevent it from slipping and sliding on the mattress surface. All mentioned toppers include elastic corner bands to securely hold them in place.
Firmness
The toppers being compared are all designed to provide a softer sleep surface. That means they will not suit those looking for a topper to provide a firmer feel when put over their existing mattresses. If your existing mattress feels a bit too hard, a 3-inch topper like Saatva’s contouring Graphite Memory Foam one may help.
Price Comparison
Although a lower price does not always mean the best mattress topper, price is an important factor for many people. The Saatva mattress toppers cost significantly less than Dormeo. That means the latter one won’t fit every household budget. Considering the quality materials in the Saatva mattress toppers, they are excellent value for the price.
Saatva Mattress Topper vs Dormeo: Comparing Pros and Limitations
In the following sections, we’ll share what we have learned about comfort, support, and other details.
How Do Comfort and Support Compare?
When it comes to choosing a leading mattress topper, comfort depends on many things, including sleep style and personal preference. While Dormeo has zoned support for some back and stomach sleepers, many side and combination sleepers may prefer the body-hugging feel of the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper. The memory foam contours to body shape and may help relieve pressure in the neck, shoulders, and hips. The responsive Saatva Natural Latex Mattress Topper offers pressure relief and support, as per certain online reviewers, which can be comfortable for many sleep styles.
Does the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Topper sound like a good fit for you? See what else buyers have to say.
See Buyer Reviews
Temperature Regulation
A lot of sleepers consider a comfortable mattress topper one that stays cool and won’t retain heat as it hugs the body. The mentioned toppers have breathable covers that promote air circulation. The Saatva Graphite Mattress Topper has naturally cooling, graphite-infused memory foam to for cooler sleep, and Saatva’s Natural Latex Mattress Topper is made with naturally breathable latex foam.
Warranty and Sleep Trial Comparison
A generous, risk-free trial is important in a top mattress topper brand. Dormeo has a 100-night sleep trial, while Saatva includes a longer 180-night trial with each topper. Being able to return the mattress topper free of charge within its trial period, meeting the related policy guidelines, can improve peace of mind as a shopper. While Dormeo requires trying the topper for 30 nights before being able to return it, Saatva recommends trying the mattress topper for a few nights but does not have a minimum adjustment period before a return. That gives you more freedom.
Both the Saatva Natural Latex and Graphite Memory Foam mattress toppers come with a 1-year limited warranty. That provides protection against workmanship defects, as per the policy terms; knowing Saatva will repair or replace the topper as per its written details about coverage shows confidence in the product quality.
Saatva Mattress Topper vs Dormeo – Final Thoughts
While only you can decide which mattress topper is best for you, the insights above can make your shopping journey easier.
Saatva’s two mattress toppers reflect the brand’s luxury reputation. From the organic cotton cover to the graphite-infused foam, the Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper uses cutting-edge materials. As for the Natural Latex Mattress Topper, it features ethically sourced, naturally buoyant and cooling latex.
We especially like the antimicrobial materials in Saatva’s mattress toppers, and that the Natural Latex one is hypoallergenic. We’re impressed with Saatva’s botanical Guardin™ treatment, which resists mold, mildew, and bacteria.
We also like the safety certifications. When bringing a mattress topper into your home, you want it to be free of harmful chemicals. Saatva includes materials that meet third-party safety and environmental standards.
Based on our research, Saatva’s mattress toppers are excellent value. In our opinion, the Saatva mattress toppers are top quality and suit many sleep styles.